Share from 0:00
0:00
/

šŸŽ™ļø NEW EPISODE: Jensen Huang Resigns

Jensen Huang resigned as Nvidia CEO this morning, and Austin Lyons and Vik Sekar recorded two hours after the news broke.

Jensen Huang resigned as Nvidia CEO this morning, and Austin Lyons and Vik Sekar recorded two hours after the news broke. They argue that a board must prioritize corporate integrity over short-term shareholder value, even for a legendary founder. The discussion then turns to Nvidia’s critical lack of a succession plan and the long-term risk of the company’s unique, founder-led culture decaying into bureaucracy.

Presented by Crusoe

Fine-tune and serve open models without managing a single GPU.

Deploy on Crusoe in one click, or download and run it anywhere. Upload a dataset, pick an open model, and pay per token rather than per GPU hour.

Accounts are free, and get $5 in credit when you sign up.

Try Serverless Fine-Tuning →

Key takeaways:

  • A board’s first duty is governance, not shareholder value. Even a founder CEO must be forced out for breaking company rules, because keeping them sends a message that lying and rule-breaking are acceptable.

  • The hardest job demands the highest standard. The immense pressure of being Nvidia’s CEO is the reason for strict conduct rules, not an excuse for leniency.

  • Nvidia has no succession plan — Ian Buck is the only plausible internal CEO candidate. Unlike competitors, Nvidia’s ā€˜all Jensen, all the time’ media strategy has left its leadership bench visibly thin.

  • Jensen’s unique management style is the biggest succession risk. His flat structure with ~60 direct reports is impossible for a successor to replicate, creating a vacuum that invites bureaucracy.

  • The real long-term risk is Nvidia decaying into a spreadsheet-CEO culture. The fear is a slide into the managerial, process-driven leadership that hampered competitors like Intel.

  • A leadership crisis at Nvidia is AMD’s opportunity to attack. For a competitor like Lisa Su, Nvidia’s moment of weakness is the time to ā€˜put my foot on the gas,’ not switch teams.

  • Arm CEO Rene Haas is a credible external successor. As an Nvidia alumnus, he understands the culture but also brings proven CEO experience from a different silicon leader.

This episode is supported by Meter.

You have the GPUs and the power. Now who builds the network, and who do you call when it breaks? Meter designs, deploys, and runs frontend, storage, and management networks on its own switches and its own network OS. One call reaches the team that designed the hardware and wrote the software.

See how Meter builds datacenter networks →

This podcast is lightly edited for clarity.

The News Breaks: Jensen Huang Resigns

Austin: Hello listeners and welcome to another Semi Doped episode. I’m Austin Lyons of Chipstrat. I write a newsletter for institutional investors and tech executives.

Vik: Hey, I’m Vik Sekar. I write a Substack newsletter called Vik’s Newsletter. And I run an advisory firm for financial institutions called Semi Exponent. And today, we are here because there is very big news in the chip world and we thought we’ll have a quick news flash about this and talk about it. Jensen Huang is no longer the CEO of Nvidia. That’s it. That’s the big news.

Austin: That’s the news. Let’s break it down.

Vik: We don’t normally talk about this type of content. Normally we focus on technology and product and business strategy and stuff. And obviously today, the topic is going to, we’re going to stick with questions like, should the board if the board forced him to resign, he resigned. That’s the news. He resigned. If the board forced him to resign, was that the right decision? We’ll let’s debate that. And then we’ll also talk, maybe we can debate kind of lighthearted, who might fill him in next. Or like who might be the next Nvidia CEO. We know that Colette Kress, the CFO is the interim CEO, but let’s talk through who it could be.

The Backstory: National Security and Corporate Policy

Austin: We should set the stage for anybody who’s listening to this and not following this stuff as closely as some other people like listening to this podcast or us included follow this kind of stuff very closely. But essentially, we have to set the stage on why we are in this situation and I say we because Nvidia is now the face of AI and what happens to Nvidia and its leader Jensen Huang affects all of us in some way, shape or form. Also, Nvidia is a large part of the S&P 500 and if something is going to move, the entire world wants to know.

So, we are in this situation and we will cover this very briefly because a lot of personal lives are involved and we don’t want to make fun of it. It’s a hard time for a lot of people. So, we want to be respectful of that and then go to talking about the technology and what we think is going to happen in the future.

So, essentially, sometime back, reports surfaced that Jensen had extramarital affairs with an executive from this company called Megaspeed, which is Singapore-based. The whole problem with that was Megaspeed supposedly was had relations to China and therefore this whole thing became a national security concern. Whether this company is using Jensen’s personal ties to supply leading edge Nvidia chips to China. So, that became the first big concern at the national level. And while that investigation is still underway to figure out what exactly is the impact and there is some movement regarding what policy changes will come towards China on that front. It is unclear still, but we might expect more tighter restrictions on China going forward because of this.

But then I think a couple of days ago, another report surfaced that there was another extramarital affair with an internal Nvidia employee. And then essentially that became a problem and for anybody who’s worked in professional environments and companies and such, companies generally frown upon this kind of stuff very severely, especially you don’t want to have relationships with somebody who’s like reporting up to you. And the reason for that is simple because workplaces is supposed to be fair and equitable and it’s based on merit. And of course, when these kinds of stuff happens, people don’t like it and companies have policies against these things.

And so, when Jensen was faced with this, in my opinion, I think the company and the board was left with no choice to but to stick to corporate policy because even the CEO is not an exception. Jensen Huang is not above the law, nobody is. And whether it’s like company policy, they had to do what they had to do. Of course, none of this is what Nvidia said is the reason why Jensen Huang resigned, but I think everybody kind of sees this the second incident as basically something he was not going to recover from.

So, we have lost the leader of a big company that is well respected. And Jensen Huang was the brainchild of Nvidia for 35 years and is probably his baby that he’s seen grow up to a $4 trillion company. And so, that accomplishment, regardless of his shortcomings or his mistakes or whatever you want to call it, that accomplishment of growing a company for multiple decades to become one of the biggest companies of the world today and one of the most important companies is something that we can’t forget and something we have to respect as a technologist and as a visionary. So, we always have Jensen as a leader of the AI movement and we will remember him proudly on that as his leadership that took us to where we are today. But now that we have an interim CEO and Nvidia is now looking for an alternative CEO to take his place, whether it’s internal or external, we don’t know. But, that’s where we are today.

Austin: This episode of Semi Doped is presented by Crusoe, where you can fine-tune and serve open models without managing a single GPU. When we sat down with Crusoe’s serverless fine-tuning product team, we asked the question every AI user wonders, what will you do with my data? Crusoe has a simple answer. They don’t touch it or see it. Your data is yours to fine-tune models with or simply store for future use. Their fine-tuning is designed so that both your training data and the fine-tune model itself remain your property. Your training data is encrypted, so even Crusoe’s cloud engineering team can’t see it. You can deploy it on Crusoe Cloud in one click or download the checkpoints and run it anywhere you’d like. The fine-tuning process is fully managed, so you upload a dataset, pick an open model, and Crusoe takes care of the GPUs, orchestration, and all the infrastructure management. You pay per token processed rather than per GPU hour, so run a few versions, compare them, and download the one that actually works best for your use case. Create a new Crusoe account for free and get $5 in credit to start testing today. This part is super important, guys. Support Semi Doped by going to semidoped.com/crusoe, click on that link in the show notes, type it in yourself, and you’ll get directed to a sign-in page. Sign in with Google or create a new account, and Crusoe will immediately create that account for you with $5 in it. Boom. Again, just click that link in the show notes, sign in, $5 for you, and you support Semi Doped. So, thank you for your support. Go check out Crusoe, try to fine-tune your own data. Again, the link to try serverless fine-tuning is in the show notes. So, hit that now, click through, and make sure you claim that $5, give it a try, and support us. Back to the show.

What Should the Board Do?

Vik: What’s your thought when this came out? Which is this news even dropped only like a couple of hours ago and we got to recording immediately. So, I haven’t had a chance to talk to you about what you think about it. So, what do you think?

Austin: Yes, this will be fresh and raw and honest. So, yes, right now we’re recording. It’s Thursday, November 12th, it’s 10:00 a.m. Central Time. So, this news came out about two hours ago and we have not talked about it. So, when I read, okay, and by the way, the news about the direct report extramarital affair thing came out just yesterday, Wednesday. And so, this has all gone down very quickly. When I saw the announcement this morning that Jensen was resigning, I thought to myself, the question I had was, if I was on the board, what would I do?

I think everyone’s chiming in on X and you can tell everyone’s biases, at least the people talking on X where I think there’s a lot of Nvidia bag holders, you could call them, people with financial interest in investment, a lot of people, right? Because by the way, not only to your point is Nvidia, whatever, 8% of the S&P 500. Also there’s a lot of other companies in the S&P 500 that also benefit from Nvidia, whether it’s HBM makers or, CPU makers, other other people in the industry. So, there will be, it’s not just one company, but everyone’s kind of intertwined.

So anyway, so the question is, what should the board do? And, there’s one argument that’s like, hey, the best thing for shareholder value is to let Jensen keep running the company because he’s built it, he has the most context, he’s gotten it to where it is. Yes, he made some mistakes, but that’s the best thing in shareholder interest. Of course, to that I would say, sure, in the short run, you can make the argument, hey, the stock’s down, whatever percent and it’d probably be down less if he was not resigning. I sort of have a different zoomed out, sort of longer term perspective, which is, and you kind of alluded to this a little bit, but what message does it send if Jensen stays? I think it sends the message that it’s okay for the leader of the company to lie, which is what happened with the Alice Huang situation where he said, hey, there’s nothing going on here and then it comes out later.

Vik: The Megaspeed employee, the first one.

Austin: The Megaspeed employee.

Vik: I have a counter take to what you say actually because I recently saw this interview of Jensen Huang with Bloomberg original, I believe. And it was a very well-produced interview and he was explaining basically what it takes to be a CEO of a company like Nvidia. The interviewer asked him, would you put your kids up to it? He was hesitant. He was like, I think they should be very careful in the decisions they make because the kind of pressure, the stress and the responsibility that you have to run the ship is enormous. And whoever the successor is, and in that interview, which was actually now come to think of it is kind of sad, he says, in 20 years, there’s going to be a successor and I hope that person can handle this job, you know, and then the moment I saw that and two days later, we are looking for a successor. It’s kind of a sad situation to be in.

But to the point that he was saying is, I think that it’s a very difficult position, a very hard job to actually hold. And you and I run a small outfit, right? Like we run a podcast, we run our substacks. You know, how many decisions we have to make on our day-to-day thing? Our listeners probably don’t really see all the naly details of running a tiny business like ours. Now, you know, multiply that and make it a $4 trillion company. It is insane, right? So I feel like, okay, why do all these rich people somehow get into this kind of scandals, right? So I feel like at some level, which I don’t really know and I don’t think I ever will understand truly, is that they have some need for an emotional connection somewhere. Their family is there for them. Yes, but I don’t know why it seems like they need something more. Maybe it’s lonely at the top. I don’t know. I’ll never find out. I’m never going to be a CEO of like Nvidia or anybody of that caliber level, really. I don’t think so. But yeah, that’s my counter argument. I don’t think it’s so much as confidence as people need some kind of emotional connection to deal with the stress they have, maybe.

Austin: Hmm.

Vik: But yeah, who knows what’s going on in his head? I don’t know. It’s all speculation.

Austin: Right, right, right. I do acknowledge it’s got to be one of the hardest jobs in the world for sure. There’s still like rules, for example, that you can and can’t break. And so regardless of how hard your job is, I want the leader that I report to or the leader that I look up to, the leader of my company to be held to the highest standard, not the lowest standard. And I think if it’s like, yes, he’s in the highest pressure job and therefore he can break company rules or he can lie. That’s like because it’s a hard job, we’re going to lower the standard for him. And so I think it’s like Jensen, this is what you signed up for. You’re taking the hardest job and you’re held to the highest standard. It’s not easy.

Vik: Yes, and you know, the benefits that come with it as a CEO, the respect, when you walk through this Computex, we were at Computex earlier this year when he walked on the floor, we couldn’t even stand. Like we had to leave the show floor because so many people piled in to see Jensen, right? Like that kind of thing, that kind of a fame and fortune comes at a price, I suppose. But anyway, what do you think is going to happen to the AI trade? Let’s get to the brass tax of what everybody’s thinking about.

The Future of the AI Trade

Austin: Well, I’m still using Claude today. I’m still using OpenAI today. It’s still very productive for me. I’m still believing that Nvidia’s roadmap will happen with Rubin Ultra and with Feynman. I think I’ll still use an x86 laptop and I think AMD will still compete with GPUs. So on the one hand, again, as we’ve been saying, this is the story of the sort of AI trade, which is always just like the value’s real, the demand is real. The stock market moves up and down on various things because they’re pricing in a future, a future value of a company.

So, obviously, what’s going to happen to Nvidia’s future? Well, all we know in the short term is, right, Jensen Huang is not leading it. In the interim, Colette is leading it. You would like to think that it’s just like, okay, run in maintain mode. Let’s not make any drastic changes. Just execute on the roadmap for the next year. In the meantime, we’re going to go figure out who the CEO, the next CEO will be and we’ll figure that out. Maybe it’s someone internal, maybe it’s someone external, we can talk through that. But you would like to think that the ship in the near term, maybe for the next year or so, could continue to keep going.

As long as because it, right, it’s obviously Jensen’s the face of the company and he’s got the 60 direct reports and clearly he has a say in everything, sort of like a Steve Jobs. On the other hand, there are lots of really smart people that work in Nvidia. And so even if the captain is not on the ship anymore, clearly everyone rowing knows the direction they’re heading and can still row and the ship will continue to go. So on the one hand, I’d like to believe that regardless of the stock price and what the weighing machine of the stock market thinks that that Nvidia can put their heads down and keep rowing and keep going. But yeah, what do you think?

Vik: So, yeah, short term, I agree that the demand hasn’t gone away, the technology hasn’t fundamentally changed, nothing has changed. All the projects internally will progress as planned, I hope. But, from having worked at big companies and I’m sure you have the same perception of this kind of stuff is that when there is a vacancy at the helm, especially a vacancy like this one, there are going to be a lot of contenders. And there’s going to be a lot of in fighting, politics, all of this takes away from what the job is at hand, which is to continue to maintain Nvidia at the leading edge of AI hardware. People lose track of that when they lose a leader like him.

You know, he had a relatively flat organization. I was reading that he has like 60 direct reports, right? He’s not like, I have three direct reports who then have 20 each or something like that, right? He’s like, he had 60 direct reports. So he was a very hands-on, culture, the culture of Nvidia was driven by his founder approach to doing things. He’s just, go directly and get it done kind of an environment. My fear, okay, in the short term, I don’t have any fear. Like, I think everything’s going to be fine. A new CEO will come and do this and that. All the sales pipelines are set up. Good positions are there, long-term agreements are in place. The scenario I fear is that somehow Nvidia sinks into—

Austin: Right, right, right. So, so you make the very good point here, which is just the difference between a founder CEO and anyone else, any other CEO that comes in. Obviously, you want to have like a founder mindset, high ownership, and I think, for example, Lit Bhutan, he came in and I think people thought like, oh yeah, he’s, he like, he’s, he’s crying because he cares so much about Intel and he has that same type of mindset. But at the end of the day, it’s just different than the Elon, Zuck, Jensen type people who started the company. They can just make decisions differently and they can think very long-term and take different risks than anyone else who comes in and you’re now the new CEO, right?

Vik: Correct. I love the example of Elon you brought up because I feel like Elon and Jensen have very similar traits. In fact, they are like extreme executors of a vision, right? Like they have a vision and they execute it to the last breath they have. Like Jensen was one such guy. Like I’ve seen his earlier interviews and he says, I was on vacation all the time. I never stopped working. My family was on vacation. I never stopped working. I kept, there was some note about how many emails he could answer in in an hour and it was something like hundreds or something like that. I’m like, how do you even read hundreds? And this was before AI, right? Like, how do you even read hundreds? So, he’s that kind of like a crazy execution guy. And I like the Elon example because supposing Elon was removed from his companies, like do you think any of that stuff will run the way it does? Right? Like, do you think somebody else could run Elon’s business the way he does?

Austin: It would definitely, definitely, definitely be different. Cuz to your point, right? Like the 60 direct reports, when Jensen’s not there to just make the executive decision, now how are they going to decide who gets more budget and who gets flat budget next year, right?

Vik: So it will fall into a bureaucracy, a red tape like situation where you’re like, oh, you need to get approval from this VP, or you need to get that approval. And then, those all flow upwards to another decision maker, moves to another decision maker. And by the time, the whole execution and the beauty of Nvidia is lost in this in this mess.

Austin: Totally, totally. So no Jensen to just say, yes, yes, no, no, no in his emails all every Sunday. And same thing with the Elons, when you think about him sleeping at the SpaceX or the Tesla or the X or whatever, just you’re going to lose that. Part of why some of these companies can move so fast too is because they have that founder who has the long-term vision and can just make those decisions quickly. And of course, you can bring in CEOs that have a vision, you know, Satya Nadella has done a nice job at Microsoft. But it’s still there’s going to be a risk, which is like, when they bring someone in, what is their vision and can they execute like that?

Who Could Be the Next CEO?

Vik: Yeah, I like your counter example of Satya Nadella. I think he really turned around Microsoft like really well. Like he adopted GitHub and the open source mindset and he really took it to a new level. Yeah, that’s a great example. I really hope somebody like that comes over and takes the helm here at some point. Who do you think that’ll be? Give me your top pick.

Austin: Okay, let yeah, let’s get into it. All right, we we can just close with this too. Okay, some names that have been floating around. Someone online said Lisa Su. Now, I’ll tell you what, Lisa Su, so when I was thinking through the example of leaders who bring out the best in people, you can hold them to the highest standard, cuz you can make the argument of like, oh yeah, Austin, you’re being very idealistic. You want so much from a CEO, but like look at all these other CEOs, they have other ones have moral failings too. But then I’m like, no, I think I can find counter arguments, and I think of like Lisa Su was the first one who popped into my mind of just like super respect, I have tons of respect for her as an engineer, as a business strategist, as a leader. And so, I think very highly of her. Now, would why would she come over to Nvidia and run Nvidia? She’s doing, she’s running AMD and they’re they’re doing awesome. So, to the people that put that on X, no.

Vik: What? No, no, no, dude, come on. Why should Lisa Su has always been trying to play catchup. Now, what if you suddenly given the the race car that wins the pole position, like as an F1 driver, would you not take that car?

Austin: Man, she’s, yeah, yeah, I think she’s always had a chip on her shoulder and she’s David trying to take down Goliath. Now does she just want to flip sides? No, I think this is the time for Lisa to dig in and say, hey, Intel just had a terrible quarter and we’re crushing on the x86 side. Nvidia’s having a hard time. This is a huge opportunity for us. If I’m her, this is where I like put my foot on the gas, not switch teams.

Vik: I totally agree. Yeah. I totally agree. Look at Nvidia, look at AMD’s position now. Like Intel is all over the place. We spoke about this on a previous podcast, like what’s going on here, right? And AMD comes right after that in their earnings call. You wrote a Substack post on this, like and they crushed it. They’re like, what happened like, do you not have sub server CPU problems? Like, we just repurposed our client, server CPU. We’re good. And that was like, whoa, okay. So you’re like really good on the CPU front and AMD is like now their biggest competitor has lost their leader. And I’m like, this is the time to go all in, right?

Austin: Yes, yes, totally. So I don’t think it’ll be Lisa Su, but what do you think? What are some other names you’ve heard floated?

Vik: I heard this is totally not going to happen, but I’m going to say it because it’s really funny. Somebody thought like Tim Cook might be the CEO.

Austin: What what was the rationale?

Vik: I don’t know.

Austin: Just cuz he came in behind Steve Jobs and Steve Jobs was the founder.

Vik: There’s no rationale to these kinds of things. It’s just yeah. Okay. Maybe, I don’t know. He’s a leader of a very big company and he’s a guy who sat why would you get a guy who sat out of the sidelines the whole time for the AI boom? He didn’t really invest in like CapEx or anything and then now you’re like, oh, just come and run this company over here that does all AI. Maybe I don’t know. It doesn’t seem likely, but

Austin: Yes, it’s a very different business. I agree that he can come in after a founder leaves and he can operationalize and make a ship work as the company grows up from startup founder stuff to like, okay, we’re like grandparents now. We’re just a company that’s been around for a long time. But yes, it’s a totally different business. I also think he’s got to be at the point in his life where he doesn’t want that. I wouldn’t know that if I was him. I’d be like, dude, I just retired.

Vik: What about Lit Bhutan?

Austin: Lit Bhutan, Intel is Intel is not doing too well.

Vik: No.

Austin: No. Yep. Pass. Uh, great guy. He needs to stay with Intel.

The Internal Candidates

Austin: Who else? I think I’ve seen floated, Madison Huang, Jensen’s daughter and she’s a VP, maybe in like, I can’t remember exactly what org. I maybe what it’s either she or his son who is like in autonomy. I don’t remember what the other like automotive autonomy. I don’t know about who does that.

Vik: Okay. Yeah, I don’t know what their roles are. Yeah.

Austin: What’s the son’s name?

Vik: But you know, we shouldn’t miss, I’m going to save the most likely one for the last. But I think we should consider Renee Haas of Arm.

Austin: Yeah, so that’s an interesting one because Renee Haas used to work at Nvidia. And so he has ties to the company, he understands the company. Also, Arm, although yes, it’s an IP business traditionally, they are getting into the Silicon game. So clearly, Renee has not lost his chops for Silicon and also those are big strategic business model changes. And so clearly, like the guy has a lot of credibility as a CEO. I think he could probably do it.

Vik: Today’s sponsor is Meter. You’ve got the GPUs and the power. Now, who builds the network and who do you call when it breaks? With Meter, it’s one call. Tell them your GPU or server count and they design, deploy and run your front-end, storage and management networks. Meter builds its own networking hardware, switches and all, and writes its own network OS. So that call goes to the team who built it. Running a new cloud or clusters in a colo, go to semidoped.com/meter. Links in the show notes.

You know, I wanted to save what I thought was a probable candidate for last. And if Nvidia promotes anybody internally, it’ll probably be Ian Buck.

Austin: Mhm. Totally.

Vik: Agreed. What do you think?

Austin: I think two things. One, yes, and—

Vik: Which is a failure of itself, right? Like how can you not have succession planning? Yeah.

Austin: 100%. And I’m sure like, I’m sure the board’s like, no, no, we have this on paper, but you can tell like, who else gets to talk at big events? Like it’s always Jensen. Yes, sometimes it’s Ian for a little bit here or various executives at these other little things over here. But at the end of the day, it’s kind of all Jensen all the time. And you don’t see it quite the same at the other companies. You can tell, even AMD is like grooming other people and they get on stage. And so literally the only person is that it could be in my estimation is Ian Buck. Can you even name any other executives that it could be? I mean, I can maybe think of like some names for like their networking business, but I can’t name any.

Vik: Yeah, I don’t know. Yeah, Ian Buck is the only name that comes to mind. Right. Right. Yeah, so maybe that’s the best option. I don’t know. Let’s wait and see. They have to announce something. And next earnings call is coming up soon. Next week, I think.

Austin: Yeah, next Tuesday. Yeah, we’ll be at Tomorrow/x. So maybe they’ll just they could just live stream it because, Jensen was supposed to talk at give a talk, like be one of the keynote speakers at Tomorrow/x. I’m guessing he won’t be there now. Maybe they can shuffle things around and just like live stream the earnings call. I think everyone would legitimately sit in and watch it together.

Vik: Yeah, or we can just ask Nvidia, hey, send in the new guy or girl.

Austin: Yeah, yeah. Right, right. Yeah, totally. Like they won’t have that figured out. So,

Vik: No.

Austin: If now the question, and we’ll just answer this later, we’ll see what happens. The question is, should it be an internal hire? And I think there’s lots of good reasons. You know, Ian Buck is known for being kind of the father of CUDA. He came out of, I think Stanford PhD and came over and built all that. There could be arguments for bringing in an external person, but both of them have big time pros and cons. So we’ll just have to discuss that later. Let’s see what happens. We’re not this will be a conversation that goes for a long time. I’m sure.

Vik: It’s true. It’s true. And we shouldn’t dedicate more than half an hour to this. That’s all we really have to say about this. Let’s see what happens. We just wanted to bring this to you quickly because it’s such a hot topic in the AI industry and we want to cover it on Semi Doped just so that we have something to talk about because it’s such a big event.

Austin: Exactly, exactly. And we said we’d keep it to 15 or 20 minutes and naturally it’s been about 28 or so. So we’re going to end it here. Thanks everyone for watching us on YouTube, for subscribing, listening on Spotify. Check out our Semi Doped daily newsletter that we write. Check us out on X. We see it all, so please give us your comments, send us ideas. We want to hear your thoughts. And we’ll catch you next time.

Discussion about this video

User's avatar

Ready for more?